Pay My Bill

Below is a list of our insurance carriers, along with their online and phone payment information. You may use the link or phone number for your carrier to pay your bill directly. You may need to have your policy number handy.

PLEASE NOTE: By clicking on any of the links below, you are leaving the Upstate Agency website and will be redirected to a trusted partner's website or other company's website. We provide links to other sites as a service to users; however third-party sites may have privacy policies and security policies different from ours. Always remember to exercise due care when accessing third-party websites.


A.Central Insurance Company
American Modern Insurance Group
Dryden Mutual Insurance
Encompass Insurance
Erie and Niagara Insurance
Foremost Insurance Group
Liberty Mutual/Peerless Insurance
Main Street America Group
Merchants Insurance Group
National General Insurance
North Country Insurance Company
NYCM Insurance
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
Safeco Insurance
Security Mutual Insurance
Selective Insurance Group
Sterling Insurance Company
Travelers--Commercial Insurance
Travelers--Personal Insurance
Utica National Insurance Group
Vermont Mutual Insurance Group

Pay by Phone

(800) 234-6926
(800) 901-1732
(800) 543-2644
(800) 694-8271
(866) 430-2916
(800) 234-9876
(800) 532-4221
(877) 922-9701
(877) 488-7488
(866) 290-2920
(888) 333-4014
(800) 462-1077
(888) 293-5108
(800) 847-7030
(800) 234-6926
(888) 511-2455
(800) 876-5581
(888) 723-3260
(800) 822-1232
(888) 974-7400
Not Available
(800) 252-2268
(877) 878-2468
(800) 598-8422
Not Available

Pay Online

Pay my A.Central bill      
Pay my Allstate bill         
Pay my American Modern bill  
Not Available    
Pay my Encompass bill  
Pay my Erie and Niagara bill  
Pay my Foremost bill     
Pay my Hagerty bill         
Pay my Kemper bill        
Pay my Liberty Mutual/Peerless bill           
Pay my Main Street America bill               
Pay my Merchants bill
Pay my National General bill      
Pay my North Country Insurance bill      
Pay my NYCM bill            
Pay my Preferred Mutual bill     
Pay my Progressive bill 
Pay my Safeco bill           
Pay my Security Mutual bill         
Pay my Selective bill      
Pay my Sterling bill         
Pay my Travelers--Commercial bill           
Pay my Travelers--Personal bill 
Pay my Utica National bill            
Pay my Vermont Mutual bill